Dr. Swank Diet and MS
fredag, januar 8, 2010 at 4:16AM Anecdotal or not – diet has been reported to have a very positive effect on MS symptoms and the progression of the disease. It is something you are in control of – at least most of the time.
Right after my diagnosis, I came across the good old book by Dr. Roy Swank “Multiple Sclerosis Diet Book”. The eating guidelines go more or less like this:
- Saturated fat should not exceed 15 grams per day.
- Unsaturated fat (oils) should be kept to 20-50 grams per day.
- No red meat for the first year.
- After the first year, 3 oz. of red meat is allowed once per week.
- Dairy products must contain 1% or less butterfat unless otherwise noted.
- No processed foods containing saturated fat.
- Cod liver oil (1 tsp. or equivalent capsules) and a multi-vitamin and mineral supplement are recommended daily.*
Thinking I had struck gold – I immediately started on this diet. For someone who was and had been living on beef, bacon, chicken, butter, milk, yoghurt, and cheese this was not easy … on top of this I lived in the Middle East where good quality fresh produce, let alone organic foods, was hard to come by.
After a few months on the diet I quit! Then after a few months I restarted, then I quit and so it went until I found that my health was actually improving and I had figured out not only how to cook without butter and cream but also how to make a vegetarian meal look and feel like a whole meal. Hurray – big revelation.
Was it really my change of diet that made me feel better?
Today after 10 years on a whole foods, mostly vegetarian, organic, low sugar diet I feel really good, but who knows maybe I would have on my old diet! This is the problem, it will never be possible to make a placebo-controlled, randomized clinical trial of the food’s impact on health. Not in relation to MS, to cardiovascular health nor to cancer.
But here is the thing, when you get diagnosed with MS at age 30 after just having given birth to your second child – do you have a choice but to trust your intuition, to trust the power of health promoting foods and to mistrust all the chemicals most people fill themselves with on a daily basis? I didn’t think so and this is what brought me here.
In an interview with Dr. Swank he is asked why every doctor doesn’t educate his or her MS patients on his diet. He answers that there is no interest because there is no financial involvement. This, I think, is very sadly true.
In the well respected book “Multiple Sclerosis Guide to Treatment and Management” written by a number of medical doctors from a variety of countries the Swank diet is mentioned and evaluated as having had a positive effect on patients studied but that as there aren't any placebo-treated group to compare these studies with they cannot be trusted. In addition, the authors go: “long-term adherence to the diet may not be possible because the recommended food is not appealing”.
Well, what do you think? Is life really terrible when eating healthy, mostly vegetarian whole foods???
Ann Boroch, author of Healing Multiple Sclerosis, thinks, and I will have to agree, that: “it is better walking around watching what you eat than sitting in a wheelchair”.
I do think that there are shortcomings in Swanks book and diet, such as:
- The use of white sugar (or sugar in general)
- Trying to make the healing diet imitate old diet - old favorites never are successful when we healthify them.
- The use of processed grains (white flour, white pasta, white rice etc.)
- The lack of emphasis on food sensitivities, gluten and dairy especially
- The lack of mentioning the importance of detoxifying the body of build up toxins such as heavy metals (mercury in teeth, old stuff from vaccines etc.)
But this is an old book, almost as old as me, that I am forever grateful having come across. My wish is that every newly diagnosed patient be it autoimmune or cardiovascular diseases, diabetes or problems with the intestinal health is at the very least encouraged to look inward, to listen to their bodies and then look at how they feed themselves.





